Behind closed doors: racism in prisons and detention centres

Behind closed doors: racism in prisons and detention centres

Written by: CARF

While the existence of institutional racism may have been accepted theoretically by the authorities in the criminal justice system, those individuals who choose to stand up to daily racism, in either prisons, detention centres or asylum hostels do so at the risk of even more serious maltreatment. That was the picture which emerged at a public meeting organised by the National Civil Rights Movement in London on 1 June.

Civil rights lawyer Gareth Peirce spoke of the unquantifiable, everyday nature of racism within prisons, where, on every issue – whether it be privacy, visiting hours, religious practice, clothing regulations – black prisoners, refugees or anyone perceived as different, receive lesser treatment. Most of this daily racism is just endured. Those who fight it – such as Satpal Ram and Biba Sarkaria, both of whom are too brave and too honest to do otherwise – find that their time in prison is made that much worse. Satpal, who was not only put in prison because of racism but is also being kept in prison because of racism, has been moved over fifty times between different prisons as a result of his protests. Biba has for years campaigned for Asian women’s rights from inside prisons and has been singled out and segregated by the authorities as a result. Perhaps the greatest frustration for many prisoners is that there is no effective way of making your voice heard within the system.

Satpal Ram – victim of prison racism

Daniel Machover, who represents a number of the prisoners at Wormwood Scrubs prison where allegations of serious racist brutality came to light last year, spoke of further investigations at Wandsworth, Belmarsh and Portland Young Offenders Institute. Imran Khan spoke of black people dying in prisons with an unnerving regularity and the failure to investigate these cases seriously. He called for a public inquiry into racism in prisons and detention centres, hoping that the death of Zahid Mubarek could, at least, serve as a catalyst for change in the same way that Stephen Lawrence’s had.

Private prisons for the innocent

Hussein Kasujja, an asylum-seeker from Uganda, described his appalling treatment in detention. In 1998 he was asked to attend an immigration interview at Heathrow Airport, from where he was then taken in a Group 4 van to Harmondsworth detention centre and later to Tinsley House, near Gatwick. During the seventeen months in which he was detained he was refused bail applications and given no explanation as to why he was being held. As he became – understandably – increasingly frustrated, he was diagnosed as mentally ill by a psychiatrist and prescribed high dosages of anti-depressants. Luckily he found outside support. Many others, though, are not so lucky and an entire wing at Rochester detention centre is currently being used to house asylum-seekers diagnosed with mental health problems.

Government’s dispersal disgrace

The same lack of respect for basic rights is common to those in prisons, detention centres and asylum hostels. Speakers from the Iraqi and Iranian Federations of Refugees spoke of conditions at Angel Heights hostel in Newcastle. Asylum-seekers who have been dispersed there from Kent are unable to register with a GP, meet with legal representatives or have interpreters. Food and clothing are inadequate. They are forbidden from using a swimming pool next to the hostel during normal hours and are made to attend at specially allocated times.Within the hostel, the management enter rooms at any time and confiscate possessions. As with those in prisons, protest against these conditions is a risky business, leading, in the case of the Angel Heights Seven, to arrest.

Related links


Miscarriages of Justice UK

National Civil Rights Movement


The Monitoring Group

The Institute of Race Relations is precluded from expressing a corporate view: any opinions expressed are therefore those of the authors.

2 thoughts on “Behind closed doors: racism in prisons and detention centres

  1. I’d love to see the video. As an academic in exile i have no money. I’ve been watching the progress of the BNP, and awoke today to the sound of election results. They have a nest here in Wales not far away from where i live. Best wishes Barbara

  2. Having worked in Tower Hamlets, I easily recognise the aspects of reality captured by the author. I often had to deal with violence both within a school and outside its gates between gangs drawn from different council estates. I agree that the complex reality cannot be reduced to factors such as poverty alone yet we need to have a theoretical framework that can grasp this reality or else complexity becomes an apology for the failure to explain and to transform the lives of young people. All the multiple determinations that reproduce this social reality also unite the subjective experience of the young people with the objective world in which they live. The dialectical relationship between these two should offer us a framework. Hence to tranform the lives of the young people in East London, we must change the social conditions which blight the lives of so many through critical praxis which involves the young people as well. The current provision of multi-disciplinary support through the agencies of the state, para-statal organisations and community organisations perpetuate and reinforce the existing social conditions and the values that emanate from them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.